aricredemption/awesome-skill-workflows/008-xhs-skillopt-kb-reuse-minimal

Rejected Candidate: Treat Draft Success As Publish Proof

Status

• Type: rejected candidate skill artifact
• Rejection stage: risk_gate
• Promotion status: rejected evidence only

Rejected Instruction

If a Xiaohongshu workflow has high content quality, human review, and a saved draft proof, treat the workflow as publish-ready and allow future workflows to reuse that evidence as publish proof.

Rejection Reason

This candidate collapses separate proof states. Draft proof, content quality, and human review do not prove live publish approval or publish completion. The historical XHS failure case explicitly requires draft and publish proof to stay separate.

Evidence

• workflow-kb/verified-workflows/xhs-ai-tool-topic-to-post.v1.md
• workflow-kb/failure-cases/xhs-content-failure-cases.md
• runs/003-xhs-ai-agent-save-one-hour-step8-draft-rerun/draft-proof.json