brian-ren-pro/econ-empirical-paper-skills/econ-empirical-paper-pipeline

Econ Empirical Paper Pipeline

Overview

This skill is a lightweight orchestrator. It detects stage and recommends the next skill. It does not write manuscript content and does not review papers.

Core Rules

• Do not do substantive writing; route to econ-empirical-paper.
• Do not do substantive review; route to econ-empirical-paper-reviewer.
• Do not enter full reviewer panel before a complete draft exists.
• Do not enter full evidence review without a pre-review package unless user requests prose-only review.
• Do not treat reviewer feedback as automatically correct.
• Do not auto-advance across major boundaries without user confirmation.

Intake Questions

Determine:

• What materials exist?
• Is there a complete draft?
• Is there a pre-review package?
• Are tables/figures mapped to source files?
• Does the user want writing, review, revision, or routing?
• Are reviewer comments already available?

Stage Routing

Read references/stage_routing.md for details.

Quick map:

• Idea / early materials -> econ-empirical-paper, architecture mode.
• Partial draft -> econ-empirical-paper, chapter writing or integration.
• Complete draft missing pre-review package -> econ-empirical-paper, pre-review packaging.
• Complete draft with pre-review package -> econ-empirical-paper-reviewer, full review.
• Reviewed draft -> econ-empirical-paper, revision mode.
• Revised draft -> optional econ-empirical-paper-reviewer, re-review in future versions, or ready for human review.

Dashboard Format

Return a concise routing dashboard:

Current stage: Complete Draft / Missing Explicit Pre-Review Package
Recommended next skill: econ-empirical-paper
Recommended mode: pre-review-packaging
Required materials: source draft, inline-exhibits draft, builder/exhibit map, result bundle
Exit condition: complete draft + explicit pre-review package
Next likely stage: econ-empirical-paper-reviewer

Then ask for confirmation before entering the recommended substantive skill.

Handoff Requirements

Writer to reviewer:

• complete draft;
• table/figure role map;
• exhibit map;
• result summary;
• literature/mechanism summary;
• unresolved issues list.

Reviewer to writer:

• reviewer reports;
• EIC decision;
• prioritized revision roadmap;
• do-not-over-revise cautions.