dif-sh/dif/dif-author-experiment

Authoring a dif experiment

Use this skill when you're drafting, editing, fixing, or iterating on a .md file under dif/experiments/active/. It covers the loop from dif new through dif validate to dif build.

Start here — read the context

Before drafting:

1. Read dif/context.json to see what experiments are currently active, on which surface, and how long they've been running. If dif/context.json doesn't exist this is a fresh repo — run dif build once to generate it, or read dif/experiments/active/*.md directly.
2. Read dif/surfaces/<your-surface>.md — the ## Learnings log shows what's already been concluded on this surface. Build on those findings; don't re-test something already answered. dif new will also embed the last 3 learnings into the draft as an HTML comment, so you'll see them again in the file. If dif/surfaces/ is empty or only has the default home.md from dif init, run the dif-generate-surfaces skill first to produce the surface set before drafting.
3. Read dif/config.yaml to see what audience attributes are declared. You can only use predicates over attributes listed there (E006); anything else needs to be added to the config first.

This isn't ceremony — the experiment file you draft is downstream of these three reads. Skipping them produces lower-quality experiments.

The happy path

dif new <kebab-id> --surface <surface-name>
# edit dif/experiments/active/<kebab-id>.md
dif validate                  # collects all errors at once
# fix any errors (see references/validation-errors.md)
dif build                     # also runs validate
git add dif/ && git commit

dif new writes a frontmatter stub with status: draft, today's date, owner from git config, and two default variants (control / variant_a at 50/50). It also embeds the surface's last 3 learnings as an HTML comment inside ## Brief. Your job is to fill in the hypothesis:, the ## Brief, the ## Rationale, and (usually) audience: and metrics:.

You can also pass --from <existing-experiment-id> to copy variants, audience, and exclusion_group from a prior experiment — useful for follow-up tests on the same surface.

What to fill in

• `hypothesis:` — one sentence, falsifiable, naming both the change and the expected primary-metric outcome for a named audience. Example: "Bolder CTA copy will lift checkout conversion on mobile by 1–3% over 14 days without regressing latency."
• `variants:` — at least two. Weights must sum to exactly 100 (E005). Keep control as the literal first id; the SDK treats it as the no-change branch. Variant ids are kebab-case.
• `audience:` (optional but usually present) — include / exclude lists of attribute predicates. Attributes must be declared in dif/config.yaml's audience_attributes. See references/audiences.md for the predicate grammar.
• `metrics: primary:` — the single metric this is moving. One primary metric per experiment, full stop. Add metrics: guardrails: for metrics that must not regress.
• `exclusion_group:` (optional) — string key that lets two experiments on the same surface coexist. The runtime picks the earlier-created: one per user. Required when E007 fires.

The body has three sections:

• ## Brief — what you're testing and why. Reference the prior learnings comment that dif new embedded.
• ## Rationale — what signal prompted this (funnel report, ticket cluster, user research). Why now, why this approach over the alternatives.
• ## Decision — leave empty. dif conclude fills this.

Anti-patterns

• A hypothesis like "see if changing the button helps" — not falsifiable, no metric direction, no audience.
• Three variants with weights 50 / 30 / 30 — sums to 110, fails E005.
• Audience predicate country: US when country isn't in audience_attributes — fails E006. Add the attribute first.
• Two active experiments on the same surface with overlapping audiences and no shared exclusion_group — fails E007. Pick: shared group, or narrow one audience so they're provably disjoint (e.g. country: US vs country: UK).
• Listing 3 guardrails "just in case" — guardrails should be real things that would change your ship decision. Three speculative ones dilute the signal.

Iterating with dif validate

dif validate collects every error in one pass and points at the file + line. Fix top-to-bottom; rerun until clean. Common shapes:

• E001 frontmatter parse error → check YAML indentation, quoting, the --- fences.
• E005 weights → distribute so they total 100.
• E006 undeclared attribute → either add it to audience_attributes (and create dif/audiences/<name>.ts) or remove the predicate.
• E007 exclusion conflict → add shared exclusion_group to both files, or narrow one audience.

See references/validation-errors.md for every code with its fix.

Autonomous experimentation

If you're proposing the experiment yourself (not implementing one a human specified): the input is dif/context.json + dif/surfaces/<surface>.md Learnings. The Learnings log is the surface's institutional memory — read all of it, not just the last three lines. Propose hypotheses that build on or contradict prior findings. Don't propose tests that re-litigate something already concluded unless the conditions have meaningfully changed.

References

• references/frontmatter.md — full schema and a complete worked example.
• references/validation-errors.md — every error and warning code with the exact fix.
• references/audiences.md — predicate grammar, the config.yaml pairing, the dif/audiences/*.ts resolver contract, and how exclusion groups differ from audience filters.