fabioc-aloha/alex_skill_mall/opt-in-workspace-writes

Opt-In for Workspace Writes

The Problem

Extensions/tools that auto-write to user workspaces without consent:

• Create .vscode/ folders unexpectedly
• Add config files that get committed accidentally
• Scaffold structures the user didn't want
• Violate the principle of least surprise

The Solution

Get explicit consent before any workspace mutation.

1. Ask First

const choice = await vscode.window.showInformationMessage(
  'Initialize Alex configuration in this workspace?',
  { modal: true },
  'Yes, create .github/',
  'No, skip'
);
if (choice !== 'Yes, create .github/') {
  return; // User declined, do nothing
}

2. Show What Will Be Created

const files = [
  '.github/copilot-instructions.md',
  '.github/config/settings.json'
];
const choice = await vscode.window.showInformationMessage(
  `This will create ${files.length} files:\n${files.join('\n')}`,
  { modal: true, detail: files.join('\n') },
  'Create Files',
  'Cancel'
);

3. Provide Undo/Remove

// After creating files
vscode.window.showInformationMessage(
  'Configuration created.',
  'Undo'
).then(selection => {
  if (selection === 'Undo') {
    // Delete the created files
    files.forEach(f => fs.unlinkSync(path.join(workspaceRoot, f)));
  }
});

Never Auto-Write These

Acceptable Auto-Behavior

• Reading files (no consent needed)
• Writing to temp directories
• Writing to user-global config (already your data)
• Writing to extension storage area

Verification

1. Fresh install → no files created until user opts in
2. User can decline and extension still works
3. Created files are clearly attributed to the extension

When to Apply

• Extension activation
• Command that generates files
• Any feature that modifies workspace

Tags

architecture extension-development ux consent