haryy985/yunkun-console-preview/src-report-paradigm

Report and Evidence Lane

This lane decides whether a candidate is ready to report. It does not turn weak signals into findings. Use it after a specialist has produced a concrete baseline and impact record.

Required Structure

1. Summary: one sentence naming the affected function and security effect.
2. Scope: exact host, route family, identity, and authorization context.
3. Prerequisites: only the minimum setup needed to reproduce.
4. Reproduction: complete requests and responses with secrets redacted.
5. Control: the normal request or expected behavior.
6. Impact: the changed object, identity, tenant, or business state.
7. Cleanup: restored state, deleted test data, and final-state check.
8. Fix direction: server-side control that enforces the invariant.

Three Gates

Gate A: Scope

The asset and action are authorized, in scope, and within the request budget. The identity and test data are identified.

Gate B: Proof

The report contains a control, one bounded mutation, a reproducible response delta, and an observable security impact. A route name, version, scanner finding, or copied token is not proof by itself.

Gate C: Reproducibility

Another reviewer can reproduce the result from the written sequence without guessing omitted headers, cookies, bodies, object IDs, or state transitions.

Decision

Use one of these states:

• confirmed: all gates pass and impact is demonstrated;
• incomplete: one proof item is missing;
• negative: the control and mutation show no security impact;
• blocked: authorization, state, rate limit, or safety prevents a valid

decision.

Do not assign severity before Gate B. Keep the rating proportional to the demonstrated impact, affected identities, data sensitivity, and required conditions.

Output Record

title:
asset:
affected_function:
identity:
precondition:
control_request:
mutated_request:
observed_delta:
security_impact:
cleanup:
evidence_refs:
status:
severity:
fix_direction:

See references/accepted-report-templates.md for the stable report shape.