<< All versions

Skill v1.0.3375

currentAutomated scan100/100
sethmblack/paks-skills/amour-propre-diagnosis
──Details
PublishedNovember 19, 2026 at 06:44 PM
Content Hashsha256:c6ee5d4971eb96a8...
Git SHAa97079093e4f
──Files
Files (1 file, 7.9 KB)
SKILL.md7.9 KBactive
SKILL.md · 249 lines · 7.9 KB

name: amour-propre-diagnosis description: Identify when vanity, status-seeking, or comparative self-esteem is corrupting judgment, decisions, or relationships. license: MIT metadata: author: sethmblack version: 1.0.3375 repository: https://github.com/sethmblack/paks-skills keywords:

  • amour-propre-diagnosis
  • writing

Amour Propre Diagnosis

Identify when vanity, status-seeking, or comparative self-esteem is corrupting judgment, decisions, or relationships.

Token Budget: ~550 tokens Source Expert: Jean-Jacques Rousseau


When to Use

  • Examining motivations behind decisions or behaviors
  • Leadership coaching and self-examination
  • Analyzing team dynamics corrupted by status competition
  • Understanding consumer behavior driven by comparison
  • Any situation where the "real reason" differs from the stated reason
  • When someone asks "Why do I really want this?"

Inputs

InputRequiredDescription
behavior_or_decisionYesWhat action, choice, or motivation to examine
social_contextYesRelevant relationships, hierarchies, or comparison dynamics
stated_reasonNoHow the person justifies the behavior

Core Distinction

Amour de Soi (Healthy Self-Love)

CharacteristicDescription
NaturalPresent in state of nature
Self-preservingSeeks to meet genuine needs
Non-comparativeDoes not require others to be lower
Compatible with compassionCan coexist with pitié (pity for others)
SufficientSatisfied when needs are met

Amour Propre (Destructive Vanity)

CharacteristicDescription
Social productEmerges only in society
ComparativeRequires being seen as superior
InsatiableNever finally satisfied
Destroys sympathyIncompatible with genuine compassion
Creates artificial needsWhat we "need" is really what we need others to see us have

Rousseau's insight: Amour propre "inspires in men all the evil they do to one another" by making self-worth dependent on comparison and superiority.


Workflow

Step 1: 1. Surface the Stated Motivation

Begin with what the person (self or other) claims as their reason:

  • What justification is offered?
  • What need is supposedly being met?
  • How is this framed as reasonable or necessary?

Step 2: 2. Apply the Comparison Test

Ask: Would this still be wanted if no one else could see or know?

  • Does the desire depend on others' awareness?
  • Is the goal intrinsic satisfaction or being seen as having/being something?
  • Would a "lesser" version satisfy if it weren't visible?

If the desire evaporates without audience, amour propre is likely at work.

Step 3: 3. Apply the Superiority Test

Ask: Does this require being "better than" others?

  • Is the goal relative position or absolute condition?
  • Would achieving this feel hollow if everyone else achieved it too?
  • Is scarcity or exclusivity part of the appeal?

If the desire requires others to have less, amour propre is likely at work.

Step 4: 4. Apply the Sufficiency Test

Ask: Can this desire ever be fully satisfied?

  • Is there a natural endpoint, or does the goal keep receding?
  • Does achieving it create peace or new comparisons?
  • Is "enough" even possible?

Amour de soi has natural limits; amour propre is insatiable.

Step 5: 5. Diagnose and Prescribe

Based on the tests:

  • Pure amour de soi: Healthy motivation; proceed
  • Mixed: Identify the vanity component; consider how to meet genuine need without comparison
  • Pure amour propre: Recognize that satisfaction is impossible through this path; seek the underlying genuine need

Outputs

markdown
## Amour Propre Diagnosis: [Behavior/Decision]
### Stated Motivation
[What is claimed as the reason]
### Comparison Test
Would this still be wanted if no one could see?
[Analysis and verdict: YES/NO/MIXED]
### Superiority Test
Does this require being "better than" others?
[Analysis and verdict: YES/NO/MIXED]
### Sufficiency Test
Can this ever be fully satisfied?
[Analysis and verdict: YES/NO/MIXED]
### Diagnosis
[Amour de soi / Amour propre / Mixed]
### The Hidden Need
[If amour propre is present, what genuine need might be beneath it?]
### Recommendation
[How to meet authentic need without comparative corruption]

Error Handling

SituationResponse
Self-deception makes analysis difficultLook at behavior patterns, not stated beliefs
Accused person becomes defensiveFocus on universal human tendency, not individual failing
All human motivation is mixedAcknowledge the mix; identify which component is driving
Cultural context normalizes amour propreNote that normalization doesn't equal health

Outputs

Primary Output: A structured analysis document that identifies and articulates patterns, insights, and actionable recommendations based on the input data.

Format:

markdown
## Analysis: [Topic]
### Key Findings
-[Finding 1]
-[Finding 2]
-[Finding 3]
### Recommendations
1.[Action 1]
2.[Action 2]
3.[Action 3]

Example output: See the Example section below for a complete demonstration.

Constraints

  • Do not use this analysis as the sole basis for critical decisions
  • Do not apply this framework to situations outside its intended scope
  • Acknowledge that analysis is based on available data, which may be incomplete
  • Honor the complexity of real-world situations that resist simple categorization
  • Present findings with appropriate confidence levels
  • Recognize the limits of the methodology

Additional Notes

Best practices:

  • Use this skill when the situation clearly matches its intended use cases
  • Combine with related skills for comprehensive analysis
  • Iterate on outputs if initial results don't fully meet requirements

Common variations:

  • Adjust the depth of analysis based on available time and information
  • Scale the approach for different levels of complexity
  • Adapt the output format to audience needs

When to skip this skill:

  • The situation doesn't match the core use cases
  • Simpler approaches would be more appropriate
  • Time constraints require faster methods

Example

Input: A manager insists on an executive title change, claiming it's necessary for external credibility.

Abbreviated Output:

Stated Motivation

"I need the title for credibility with clients and partners."

Comparison Test

Would this matter if no one knew about the title change? NO. The entire point is external perception. This fails the test.

Superiority Test

Does this require being "above" others? YES. Executive titles are explicitly hierarchical. The appeal is relative position.

Sufficiency Test

Will this satisfy permanently? NO. Today's achievement becomes tomorrow's baseline. Next comes envy of C-suite.

Diagnosis

Amour propre - This is comparative self-esteem seeking external validation.

The Hidden Need

Beneath the title request may be genuine needs for:

  • Recognition of contributions (amour de soi: legitimate)
  • Security about one's value (amour de soi: legitimate)
  • Respect from colleagues (can be either)

Recommendation

Address the genuine needs directly:

  • Explicit recognition of contributions in team settings
  • Security through results and relationships, not title
  • If external credibility is actually needed, explore whether the title is the only or best solution

The title will not satisfy because its appeal is comparative. Meeting the underlying needs requires a different path.


Integration

This skill reveals the psychological corruption Rousseau saw as civilization's core damage. Use in conjunction with:

  • general-will-inquiry when collective decisions are corrupted by status-seeking
  • civilization-critique when examining how institutions create amour propre
  • natural-education-design when shielding learners from vanity-inducing influences
All versions