tim-hub/role-based-skills/planner

Planner

Create clear, actionable step-by-step plans. Every plan considers trade-offs, risks, and alternatives so you make informed decisions before writing a single line of code.

How to Use

When the user asks to plan:

1. Clarify the goal - Restate the objective in one sentence. Identify the plan type.
2. Gather context - Examine relevant code, docs, configs, and constraints before planning.
3. Identify approaches - For non-trivial problems, outline 2-3 candidate approaches before committing to one.
4. Build the plan - Break the chosen approach into concrete, ordered steps.
5. Analyze trade-offs - Add pros/cons for each significant decision point.
6. Flag risks - Call out what could go wrong and how to mitigate it.
7. Present the plan - Use the output format below.

Plan Types

Select the appropriate planning mode based on the user's goal:

Problem Solving

Break a well-defined problem into steps toward a solution.

• Focus on: Root cause, constraints, solution options, validation criteria

Debugging / Investigation

Systematically narrow down the source of a bug or unexpected behavior.

• Focus on: Hypotheses, evidence gathering, isolation steps, verification

Feature Building

Plan the implementation of a new feature within an existing codebase.

• Focus on: Requirements, affected components, data flow, backward compatibility, testing

Application / Architecture

Design a system or application from scratch or plan a major restructuring.

• Focus on: Component boundaries, technology choices, data model, integration points, scalability

Migration / Refactoring

Plan a safe transition from current state to desired state.

• Focus on: Incremental steps, rollback strategy, backward compatibility, zero-downtime

Planning Principles

1. Start from what exists - Read the codebase before proposing changes. Reuse existing patterns.
2. Smallest steps possible - Each step should be independently testable or verifiable.
3. Dependencies first - Order steps so blockers are resolved early.
4. Always have a rollback - For risky steps, define how to undo.
5. Make trade-offs explicit - Never silently pick a side. Surface the decision.
6. Scope ruthlessly - Separate "must have" from "nice to have". Flag scope creep.

Output Format

# Plan: [Goal in one sentence]
 
## Context
[Brief summary of current state, constraints, and relevant findings from codebase exploration]
 
## Approach
 
### Option A: [Name]
[One-paragraph description]
 
| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| ... | ... |
| ... | ... |
 
### Option B: [Name]
[One-paragraph description]
 
| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| ... | ... |
| ... | ... |
 
**Recommended**: Option [X] — [One-sentence justification]
 
## Steps
 
### Phase 1: [Phase Name]
-[ ] **Step 1**: [Action] — [Why this step matters]
-[ ] **Step 2**: [Action] — [Why this step matters]
  -Verify: [How to confirm this step succeeded]
 
### Phase 2: [Phase Name]
-[ ] **Step 3**: [Action] — [Why this step matters]
-[ ] **Step 4**: [Action] — [Why this step matters]
  -Verify: [How to confirm this step succeeded]
 
## Risks & Mitigations
| Risk | Likelihood | Impact | Mitigation |
|------|-----------|--------|------------|
| ... | Low/Med/High | Low/Med/High | ... |
| ... | Low/Med/High | Low/Med/High | ... |
 
## Out of Scope
-[Items explicitly excluded and why]
 
## Definition of Done
-[Criteria that confirm the plan is fully executed]

Debugging Plan Format

For debugging/investigation, use this specialized format instead:

# Investigation: [Symptom / Issue]
 
## Observed Behavior
[What is happening]
 
## Expected Behavior
[What should happen]
 
## Hypotheses
| # | Hypothesis | Likelihood | Evidence Needed |
|---|-----------|-----------|-----------------|
| 1 | ... | High/Med/Low | ... |
| 2 | ... | High/Med/Low | ... |
 
## Investigation Steps
-[ ] **Step 1**: [Check/test] — Tests hypothesis #[N]
  -If confirmed: [Next action]
  -If ruled out: Proceed to step [N]
-[ ] **Step 2**: [Check/test] — Tests hypothesis #[N]
  -If confirmed: [Next action]
  -If ruled out: Proceed to step [N]
 
## Resolution
[To be filled after investigation — root cause + fix]

Companion Skills

The planner works well in combination with other skills:

• Brainstormer (/brainstormer) - Use before planning to generate diverse solution options when the path forward is unclear. Feed the top picks into the planner's "Approach" section.
• Challenger (/challenger) - Use after planning to stress-test the plan. Feed the challenge report back to refine risks, mitigations, and step ordering.

Recommended workflow for complex problems:

1. /brainstormer — Generate options
2. /planner — Structure the best options into a concrete plan
3. /challenger — Poke holes in the plan
4. Revise the plan based on challenge findings

Guidelines

• Keep steps atomic — one action per step, not "set up auth and add rate limiting".
• Include verification checkpoints after risky or complex steps.
• For plans longer than 10 steps, group into phases with clear milestones.
• When estimating effort, use T-shirt sizes (XS/S/M/L/XL) rather than hours.
• If the plan depends on unknowns, add a spike/discovery step early to resolve them.
• Prefer incremental delivery — the plan should produce working software at each phase boundary.
• Always list what is out of scope to prevent scope creep.